Dynamics of Health Status of Residents in the Lugyny District after the Accident at the ChNPS

Ivan Godlevsky and Oleg Nasvit*

Hospital of the Lugyny Territorial Medical Association;

23 Chervonoyi Girky str., Lugyny village, Lugyny district, Zhytomyr Region, Ukraine

*Institute of Hydrobiology, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine;

12 Geroev Stalingrada, Kyiv 254210, Ukraine

 

Introduction

The Lugyny district lies in the northern part of the Zhytomyr region of Ukraine within 110-150 km from the Chernobyl nuclear power station (ChNPS). Its territory is crossed by the southern and south-western tracks that were formed by the Chernobyl accident in April 1986. The total territory of the district constitutes approximately 900 km2, the territory of agricultural land ? more than 300 km2, and about 190 km2 of them arable land. Practically all agricultural land in the district have the 137Cs contamination density higher than 1 Ci/km2 (Table 1).

Table 1. Territory of agricultural land of the Lugyny district with different 137Cs contamination density levels, km2

Contamination density Ci/km2

Agricultural land

Total agricultural land

Arable land

up to 1

5

2

from 1 to 5

283

162

from 5 to 15

42

25

higher than 15

02

1

Total

332

190

Prior to the Chernobyl accident about 30 thousand residents were living in the Lugyny district. By the present moment the population of the district has dropped to approximately 22 thousand people due to resettlement from the most contaminated territories and the decrease in the birth-rate (Table 2).

Table 2. Population of the Lugyny district in 1984-1996

Years

Total

Children total

Infants under 1 year

1984

30,049

6,536

445

1985

29,575

6,500

401

1986

29,276

6,500

456

1987

29,225

6,296

296

1988

28,467

5,809

359

1989

27,962

5,819

300

1990

27,420

5,595

200

1991

25,046

4,799

317

1992

24,803

4,643

335

1993

24,883

4,700

352

1994

23,903

4,525

304

1995

23,125

4,389

264

1996

22,552

4,327

269

 

1. Radiation situation within the Lugyny district

All settlements of the Lugyny district (50 in total) according to [1] are categorised as zones of radioactive contamination II, III and IV (see Table 3), and practically all population are qualified for different categories of the accident sufferers (Table 4).

Table 3. Number of settlements and population size in territories categorised as different zones of radioactive contamination

Zones

Number of settlements

Number of inhabitants

Zone ofobligatory resettlement (zone II)

4

314

Zone of guaranteed voluntary resettlement (zone III)

35

18,815

Zone of intensified radio-ecological control (zone IV)

11

3,423

Total

Table 4. Number of inhabitants of the Lugyny district qualifying for different categories of sufferers

Categories

Total number of inhabitants

Children

I

232

49

II

18,949

2,666

III

3,173

608

Total

22,354

4,323

Local authorities constantly have been taking measures to resettle the inhabitants in the zone of obligatory resettlement (zone II). However, many of these inhabitants refuse to leave, others return to their homes after resettlements. The number of resettled from the 1st of January 1996 to the 1st of July 1997, as well as the number of inhabitants of 4 settlements in the zone of obligatory resettlement on the 1st of July 1997, are given in Table 5.

Table 5. Number of inhabitants of settlements in zone II by 01.07.97

Settlement

Number of inhabitants resettled from 01.01.96 to 01.07.97

Number of inhabitants remaining on 01.07.97

village Malahovka

34

64

village Rudnya Povtchanskaya

22

194

village Rudnya Zherevtsy

13

51

village Moschanitsa

2

5

Total

In 48 settlements of the Lugyny district, i.e. in all except the completely resettled Granitny Karier, and Moschanitsa where only 5 inhabitants are remaining, a regular dosimetric monitering of lands is performed. According to its results, the registered annual dose rate (Fig. 1), in 7 settlements of the district does not exceed 0.5 mSv/year, i.e. the criterial limit of qualifying as zone of intensified radiological control. None of the registered dose rate reach the value to be qualified for of obligatory resettlement (>5mSv/year). 22 and 19 settlements are qualified to be zones of guaranteed voluntary resettlement and intensified radiological control, respectively.

Regular examinations of inhabitants in settlements qualified for zones of radioactive contamination are performed with use of whole-body counters. Within the 8-year period (from 1989 to 1996) a total of 33,085 adults and 11,016 children has been examined. Radionuclide accumulation exceeding the control norm is found by 3,026 adults and 1,029 children (Table 6). The control norms of 137Cs in the organism are 0.5 µ Ci for adults and 0.2 µ Ci for children.

Fig. 1. Number of settlements of the Lugyny district which fit the criteria to be qualified for different zones of radioactive contamination (according to [2])

Table 6. Results of dosimetric control of internal irradiation of the district population living in settlements with soil contamination from 5 to 15 Ci/km2 and higher

Years

Number of examined persons

Found with dose exceeding norm, persons

Found with dose exceeding norm,

%

Adults

Children

Adults

Children

Adults

Children

Total

1989

3,198

696

417

103

13

14.7

13.3

1990

8,432

2,296

809

280

9.5

12.1

10.2

1991

5,550

2,685

603

192

10.8

7.1

9.6

1992

3,892

1,636

432

186

11.1

11.3

9.3

1993

3,164

1,037

167

42

5.2

4

4.9

1994

2,156

534

372

164

17.2

30

19.9

1995

1,697

1,415

41

38

2.4

2.6

2.5

1996

4,996

717

185

24

3.7

3.3

3.6

Dynamics of the relative number of cases with 137Cs accumulation in organism of adults and children in excess of the control norms is indicated in Fig.2. A significant increase is observed in 1994 in the background of a general trend towards a decrease. Such splash is explained in the first place by changes in natural conditions, in particular in the rainfall amount and cropping capacity of wild mushrooms and berries. According to the data of radiometric control of foodstuffs in the district, radionuclide accumulation in human organisms is contributed by consumption of milk, mushrooms and berries by the population of the district. Excess of all-union Tentative Acceptable Levels (TAL-91) is 3-5% for milk, 1-5% for meat, 50% for mushrooms and berries for the period of 1993-1995.

Fig. 2. Dynamics of changes in the relative number of cases with 137Cs accumulation in organism of adults and children in excess of the set control values

Comparison of the internal irradiation dose year by year shows the following: until 1990 maximal registered values of 137Cs in adults exceeded 10 µ Ci, and beginning from 1991 the maximal values in general constituted 2 µ Ci in adults and 0.6 µ Ci in children.

According to the data of the UKP "Truskavets" 2,020 children and parents living in the radiation contaminated territory of the district have been examined. In 80% of children the radio-caesium activity was found to be higher than 1,000 Bq, in 15% ? higher than 5,000 Bq.

The relative number of inhabitants with excessive 137Cs accumulation is significantly higher in zones with higher levels of radioactive contamination (Table 7).

Table 7. Results of dosimetric examination of the internal irradiation of the inhabitants of the district, living in settlements in zones II-IV

Year

Zone II

Zone III

Zone IV

Total

With excessive dose

Total

With excessive dose

Total

With excessive dose

1996

155

103 (66%)

4,755

104 (2%)

803

2 (0.2%)

1997

24

3 (13%)

1,749

21 (1%)

283

-

According to the data of the thyroid dosimetric conditioning of settlements in the Zhitomir region performed by the UNCRM in 1994 by the request of the Ministry of Chernobyl of the Ukraine, inhabitants of the Lugyny district had received high thyroid irradiation doses during the first stage after the accident, especially children (Fig. 3). In 38 of 50 settlements in the Lugyny district thyroid irradiation doses by children born in 1986 exceed 90 cGy.

Fig. 3. Distribution of the number of settlements in the Lugyny district according to thyroid irradiation doses for children born in 1986 (according to [3])

The population is divided into seven age-groups in the thyroid dosimetric registration and the relative distribution of thyroid irradiation doses for different age-groups of the population residing in the same settlement is given in Fig. 4.

Group

Year of birth

1

1986

2

1983-1985

3

1979-1982

4

1975-1978

5

1971-1974

6

1968-1970

7

before 1968

Fig. 4. Relative thyroid gland irradiation doses for different age-groups of inhabitants residing in the same settlement

 

2. Health status indices of the Lugyny district

The medical system of the former Soviet Union was succeeded by the Ukrane, as well as its merits and demerits. It constitutes one kind of hierarchy structure of medical institutions, ranking from national medical centres down to hospitals in regions, districts, and towns (villages). Within the structure of this system, one central hospital is distributed in each district. In the Lugyny district we can, therefore, collect all medical information of the population at the Hospital of the Lugyny Territorial Medical Association (which is the central district hospital) district where one of the present authors is working.

As indices of the health status, we shall analyse state of the immune system, spread of endocrine pathologies, morbidity by newly-born, psycho-neurological status of the population, premature ageing, and structure of mortality.

 

The immune system

The state of the immune system is one of the most important indices of the health status. According to the data of the Central District Hospital of the Lugyny district, depression of reactivity of the immune system is found practically by all patients. This depression is clinically manifested through the increase in the number and duration of infectious diseases, growth of destructive forms of tuberculosis, relapse of diseases, increase in the number of frequently ill people, reduction of remaining life of oncology patients after their diagnosis, a more severe course of diseases, increase in virulence of infecting agents, as well as growth of the number of allergic diseases.

Investigation of medical records of the patients suffering from malignant tumours has disclosed the following regularity: after the accident at the Chernobyl NPS the remaining life of such patients after the moment of their diagnosis decreases with every year. Before the accident, in 1984-1985 the remaining life of patients with grade III-IV cancer of stomach was about 60 months after the moment of diagnosis, with grade III-IV pulmonary tumours ? about 40 months. In 1992 the remaining life made up 15.5 months in the case of grade III-IV cancer of stomach and 8 months in the case of grade III-IV lung cancer, and in 1996 ? 2.3 and 2 months (!!!) respectively (Table 8). At the same time the detection techniques, diagnostics and treatment remain at the level of the pre-accident years.

Table 8. Remaining life of patients in the Lugyny district with grade III-IV malignant tumours of the stomach and lungs after the moment of diagnosis before and after the Chernobyl accident, (in months)

Years

Remaining life by cancer

stomach

lungs

1984

62

38

1985

57

42

-

-

-

1992

15.5

8.0

1993

11.0

5.6

1994

7.5

7.6

1995

7.2

5.2

1996

2.3

2.0

Where does the reason of such difference in the remaining life lie? The importance of the immune system for viability of organism has become especially evident after the accident at ChNPS. The immune system plays an important role in maintenance of stable internal environment of the organism and is involved in anti-tumour protection. Effects of radiation expose the immune system to extreme stress with subsequent development of immune deficiency, which in turn results in progressing of malignant diseases, as well as in contraction of incurable infection and associated diseases, that are generally the cause of death of such patients

Special concern of physicians is also caused by the growth of the number of destructive forms of tuberculosis among the first detected tuberculosis cases (Table 9), which is also an evidence of the depression of the immune system.

Table 9. Dynamics of the number of the first detected tuberculosis cases in the Lugyny district, per 100 thousand inhabitants

Years

All forms, per 100 thousand inhabitants

Destructive forms among first detected cases, %

1985

75.8

17.2

1986

84.5

28.7

1987

64.0

17.7

1988

54.7

14.5

1989

91.2

37.5

1990

12.2

66.6

1991

28.4

42.3

1992

49.8

33.3

1993

53.9

54.5

1994

59.8

50.0

1995

73.3

50.0

1996

84.0

41.7

By an order of the administration of Health Care authorities, the number of roentgeno-photography examinations in the framework of sanitary observation programmes was sharply decreased in 1990 in order to prevent unjustified additional irradiation of the population. Namely this fact explains the drop in the number of the first detected tuberculosis cases in 1990 as compared to the previous year (Table 9). The drop in 1990 was not the actual decrease in the number of tuberculosis patients. Subsequently, after renovation of the roentgeno-photography rooms and installation of more up-to-date equipment, the roentgenophotography examinations have been resumed to the initial extent.

 

 

Endocrine pathology

Endocrine pathology includes diffuse goitre, nodular goitre, diabetes mellitus, liposis and others. Special concern is the growth of endocrine pathology in children. Beginning from 1990-1991 a stable increase in the number of endocrine system diseases in children is observed (Fig. 5). Prior to 1986 morbidity of endocrine pathology did not exceeded 10/1000. Nodular and diffuse goitres had not been registered in the district at all. By analysis of thyroid morbidity, it is noted that the sufferers are mainly children who were subject to the iodine strike in 1986, when no prophylactics was performed. Iodine potassium prophylactics was started 3 weeks after the accident. Thyroid gland pathology is also observed in adults. Unfortunately, there are practically no medical facilities and financial means to conduct specialised examinations of the population aimed at detection of nodular goitre. Tumours of thyroid gland have not been registered within the period since the accident. However, a significant increase in the number of thyroid gland hyperplasia is established (Fig. 6). Hyperplasia (enlargement) of thyroid gland is not an illness proper, but indicates the reaction of the organism to external injurious effects. Before 1988 hyperplasia of thyroid gland was not registered in the district; at present it is typical of almost half of the children in the district.

Fig. 5. Dynamics of the growth of endocrine pathology and goitres in children after the Chernobyl accident (per 1,000 children)

Fig. 6. Dynamics of the number of thyroid gland hyperplasia in children (per 1,000 children)

 

Morbidity in newly-born

A growth of the morbidity in newly-born (age of up to 7 days) is marked after the Chernobyl accident, as well as the number of their anomalies (Fig. 7). Dynamics of newly-born anomalies (they are cleft lip, atresia of internal organs), shows a more complex tendency in the post-accident period. However, as Fig. 8 shows, their average level in the period after 1988 is several times as large as the pre-accident level.

Fig. 7. Morbidity in newly-born (age of up to 7 days), including inherent development anomalies in children (per 1,000 newly-born).

 

Fig. 8. Dynamics of inherent development anomalies in newly-born (absolute number)

 

Psycho-neurological disorders

Of the most important problems which physicians had to face suddenly and which have been continuously aggravated ? is psychological pathology. More and more patients go to physicians with anxiety-depression syndromes and different phobias. Predominant symptoms are neurosis-like conditions, and asthenic and psycho-chondric symptoms that are manifested by way of anxiety, fear and emotional imbalance.

Apparently, as a result of the combined effect of ionising radiation and psycho-emotional stress on the organism, its homeostasis is impaired and an endogenic intoxication emerges, which are leading to psycho-neurological disorders. It is possible as well that low radiation doses determine dysfunction of brain structures, which are being manifested through significant increase of vegeto-vascular dystonia with diencephalic syndromes. Before the accident, practically no cases of vegeto-vascular pathology were registered. At present, this pathology is one of the most widespread causes for people to see physicians.

Physicians faced the problem of psycho-neurological disorders only in the last 4 years. Today, one needs to realise the responsibility to cope with these psychosomatic disorders and diseases because an increase in the number of suicides and severe psychic diseases is to be expected in the future.

Premature ageing

In the course of life process, more and more cells are decaying due to effects of internal and external irradiation factors. This leads to premature ageing and shortening of life span. The fact of early ageing is confirmed by markers of ageing in younger ages. These markers include different tests that determine capabilities of all systems of the organism, e.g. for the cardiovascular system ? blood pressure, rapid pulse in young ages, statistically reliable increase in the number of hypertension and ischemic cases in young ages; for nervous system ? increase in the number of anxiety-depression syndromes, phobic neurosis-like conditions arising on somatic grounds and others. All of these phenomena can be easily checked in clinical observation.

What has been influencing on the increase of ageing pathologies and associating premature deaths? The major factors are ? the increased level of radiation and presence of permanent stress situations. Mechanisms of the effects of these factors are practically the same: their direct or indirect impact on the systems and organs impairs metabolism and circulation of blood, which results in dystrophic processes in organs and systems of the organism determining premature ageing and death. Average life-expectancy of the Lugyny district population before the accident at the Chernobyl NPS (1984, 1985) has been 75 years, after the accident (1990-1996) ? 65 years.

Mortality structure

According to the mortality data, after the accident death has become 10 years "younger" than before the accident and the mortality peak falls on the age of 65-69 years (Fig. 9). Women live approximately 8 years longer than men. The total mortality of the population in 1985 in the district was 10.9 per 1,000 inhabitants with maximum mortality in the age of more than 80 years. Oncologic diseases occupied the third place in the mortality structure with an index of 0.7. The first and second places were occupied by cardiovascular diseases (6.5) and diseases of the respiratory organs (1.7), respectively. In the age structure of mortality a smooth rise of the curve was found to the 80-years age in both men and women, with a 10 year longer life expectancy for women.

In 1990 the total mortality was 12.9 per 1,000 inhabitants. As seen in Fig.9, a mortality increase of step character can be noted in the 50-54 years interval (0.8 per 1,000), and a second peak in the 65-69 years interval (1.9). As compared to 1985, the life-expectancy for men in 1990 has dropped by 10 years. In the case of women, the mortality curve is still smoothly rising with a peak on the 65-69 years interval. The life-expectancy for women was 10-15 years longer than for men. Mortality from oncologic diseases was 1.9 per 1,000 inhabitants and moves to the second place after cardiovascular diseases (5.7).

Fig. 9. Age structure of mortality in the Lugyny district in the pre- and post-accident periods

The total mortality in 1991 has increased and was 15.5 per 1,000 inhabitants. The mortality curve of men sharply stepped up with a peak in the 50-54 years interval (0.8) and kept the increased level till 65-69 years. In women the mortality curve is still smoothly rising with a peak on the 60-64 years. On the average, the life expectancy for men was 15 years shorter than for women. Mortality from oncologic diseases occupied the second place (1.6) after cardiovascular diseases (7.3).

The age-profile of mortality of men in 1990-1992 as compared to 1985 clearly indicated that death came 15 years earlier in men than in 1985. Peak of the mortality curve of men has moved to younger ages, indicating that more younger men will die in the future. As far as mortality of women is concerned, the mortality curve has been moving slower and in comparison with 1985 the life expectancy was 5-8 years shorter.

Conclusion

At first it should be noted that the immune system of inhabitants in the Lugyny district is depressed. This fact is indicated by the followings: drop in remaining life of oncologic patients, reduction of the periods between stages of oncologic diseases, a more severe course of diseases, increase in the destruction of lungs on the background of growth of tuberculosis of lungs, increased morbidity of children, and increase in the number of infectious diseases.

The increase in the number of nodular goitres in the background of a significant growth of thyroid gland hyperplasia in children occupies the second place.

In the third place is a yet incomprehensible for us physicians psycho-neurological aspect with its anxiety-phobic depression syndromes, which will lead to unpredictable consequences in future.

A growth of the morbidity in newly-born is established, to be more exact ? the prenatal morbidity of the foetus (e.g., inherent pneumonia, etc.).

More and more cases of vegeto-vascular dystonia with diencephalic syndromes are registered.

Premature ageing and a significant reduction of life expectancy is found in inhabitants of the district.

References

  1. Decree of Cabinet of Ministers of the Ukrainian SSR of July, 23, 1991, No.106, with changes and additions introduced by the Instructions of Cabinet of Ministers of January, 12, 1993, No.17-p and of January, 27, 1995, No.37-p.
  2. General dosimetric passport registration system of settlements of Ukraine, which were subjected to radioactive contamination after the Chernobyl accident. Generalised data for 1996. Collection 6. Health Ministry of Ukraine, AMSU, Ministry of Emergencies of Ukraine, SCRM of AMSU, Inst. Radiol. Protect. of ATSU. - Kyiv, 1997. - 103 p.
  3. Thyroid dosimetric passport registration system of settlements of Zhytomyr region. Approved by Chief sanitary inspector of Ukraine, Health Ministry of Ukraine and NCRP of Ukraine. - Kyiv, 1994. - 45 p.